Book Review #4 - First-Time Caller by B.K. Borison

📚 The Plot

First-Time Caller is the fourth book in the Lovelight series, but it holds its own as a standalone (though you’ll want to devour the others after this). The story centers on Mabel, a radio host whose late-night call-in show becomes the unlikely setting for a budding connection with a mysterious stranger—Cameron, a broody but endearing mechanic from a neighboring town.

What starts as a playful, slightly awkward first call turns into a ritual. Mabel and Cameron’s conversations are filled with humor, vulnerability, and that delicious slow-burn tension we live for in romance. The anonymity of radio allows them to open up in ways they haven’t with anyone else—and when their paths finally cross in real life, the chemistry is undeniable.

💬 What I Loved

✅ The concept is original and charming. A late-night radio romance? Yes, please. The dialogue is snappy and sincere, giving the characters real depth.

✅ Mabel is such a relatable heroine. She’s smart, a little chaotic, and deeply caring—especially about her listeners and her town. I loved being inside her head and watching her growth throughout the book.

✅ Cameron is peak soft grump. He’s introverted, quiet, and guarded at first, but through their calls and eventual real-life interactions, you get to see his warm, thoughtful side unfold. He’s not flashy, but he’s solid—and totally swoon-worthy.

✅ The banter is top-tier. B.K. Borison has a gift for writing quick, clever, and emotionally rich conversations. The chemistry between the leads feels natural and genuine.

✅ The Lovelight world is full of cozy charm. If you’re a fan of small-town settings that feel like a warm hug (à la Stars Hollow from Gilmore Girls), this is your vibe. Returning characters and familiar places make it feel like home.

🧡 Final Thoughts

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)
Genre: Contemporary Romance
Tropes: Small-town romance, anonymous late-night calls, slow burn, opposites attract
Vibe: Cozy, heartfelt, witty, and emotionally layered
Spice Level: 🌶🌶 (Sweet with a few swoony moments)

First-Time Caller is a heartwarming, cozy romance that’s both comforting and emotionally satisfying. With lovable characters, a creative premise, and tender moments, it’s perfect for fans of Emily Henry, Abby Jimenez, or small-town love stories with a twist.

It’s a gentle reminder that connection can come from the most unexpected places—and sometimes, the best love stories begin with a simple “Hello?”

🔍 Minor Critique

There were a few pacing dips in the middle where the emotional build-up took precedence over action—but honestly, for fans of character-driven romance, it’s a minor quibble. The payoff is worth the slow simmer.

Would I recommend it? Absolutely.

Would I call into Mabel’s radio show? Every night. 🎙️💕

Until the next page, happy reading! 📖✨

XoXo Plot Threads